It's a jolly good question! It also made me realise it was a topic which I'd not researched - although I already knew of some links.
So much so that I've decided to employ the "wisdom of crowds" and invite you all to contribute to an exercise to identify useful links and suggest what you think is important.
I'll produce a revised summary of advice, tips and techniques after you've all had a chance to respond.
How to Critique Art - links to sites providing advice
First of all here are some links to advice which can be found on the Internet. These are included in my new 'resources for artists' information site - How to Critique Art - Resources for Artists
- How to critique artwork like a pro - by Jamie K Mackintosh (Twisted Textiles). This includes the following quote
In order “properly” to critique any given artwork (in a way that is acceptable by any institution assigning four-digit numbers to its classes), you need only remember the acronym “DAIJ.” It stands for “Description, Analysis, Interpretation, Judgment,” or as a clever student in my highschool art class once said, “Dem Apples Is Juicy.”
- Teaching Students to Critique By Joyce Payne ArtsEdge, Kennedy Arts Centre (The National Arts and Education Network) - which follows the DAIJ model. This is a straightforward explanation which is very accessible.
- How to read a painting by the Keystone Central School District -includes a structured approach with tips about objectives, the process, available resources (if you want to practice on paintings by past masters), an assessment method and some examples of critiques by sixth grade students
- Smart-Soft Critique by Marvin Bartel © 2002 (Goshen College). This in a highly structured approach and includes different aspects of a Successful Art Class Critique :
- a printable Art Critique Sheet student handout
- a page of explanation to accompany the student handout critique form
- an Art Rubric - an artwork assessment form (not the same as class critique),
- a Rubric to Assess the Critique Discussion and Writing about art, click here
- Teacher Instructions for Critique Response Form for Art Students
- Marion Boddy-Evans, the About.com Guide for About.Com: Painting has developed a mini series of articles on this topic:
- How to Critique a Painting - Tips to help you comment constructively when giving a painting critique By Marion Boddy-Evans, About.com Guide
- Painting Critique Checklist - Things to consider when looking at a painting. By Marion Boddy-Evans, About.com Guide
- Painting Critiques: 10 Things Never to Say About a Painting. There are some things you shouldn't say when asked if you like a painting.
- How to Deal with Criticism About Your Art. Dealing with Criticism: When Someone Laughs at Your Painting
- How to critique art by This appears to be a complete website produced by Keith Opstad, It provides the structure for an approach to critiques and provides tools, but I had problems getting all the pages to load.
- How to Survive an Art School Critique on wikihow - very simplistic, but does contain some useful tips for those being critiqued
- How to critique artwork - an e-how article (Note: this assumes prior knowledge of the principles and elements of design and composition)
- Looking at Painting - Abstraction—Critique of Art by Kentucky Educational Television (KET)
First ArtLex Art Dictionary which provides a useful resource for art terms
Let's also not forget the The Instant Art Critique Phrase Generator which is always good for a laugh if the 'high falutin'' language we often read in critiques gets too much for you! This was its response after entering a family members birth date
I find this work menacing/playful because of the way the sublime beauty of the purity of line makes resonant the larger carcass.The wisdom of crowds - what are your suggestions?
- Do you have any personal advice as to approaches to adopt when critiquing art?
- for those providing the critique
- for those whose work is the subject of the critique
A number of the sites assume familiarity with technical aspects of how an artwork is out together. Below are more of my 'resources for artists' sites which some people might find helpful.
Composition and design for artists
- Composition and Design - Resources for Artists You can use composition and design to help to make your artwork more more pleasing to the eye. This lens contains links to - information and advice about composition and design for artists. - various books concerned with composition and design.
- The Best Art Books - Composition and Design This site identifies leading art books about composition and design and includes reviews of art books about composition and design. It's linked to Composition and Design - Resources for Artists
Colour: What is colour and how can you use it
- Colour - Resources for Artists What is colour? Do you know or do you want to learn more about colour and its use as an artist? This site provides links to information and advice about colour and how to understand and analyse it - and then use it as an artist.
- Colour science, systems and models - Resources for Artists If you want to understand more about the science of colour, how it works and how people think (or thought) it works then this is the site for you.
- The Best Art Books - Colour This site identifies leading art books about colour and includes art book reviews - for books about understanding colour, using colour, mixing colour. It was created out of The Colour Project on Making A Mark which involved book reviews by various artists.