Friday, November 20, 2026

Review: Episode 7 of Portrait Artist of the Year 2026

This is my review of the BEST HEAT YET in Portrait Artist of the Year 2026 in the 13th Series of this popular art competition on television.

Portrait Artist of the Year 2026: Episode 7
Artists line up for the shortlisting announcement

As ever, my review follows my standard format for each review of Portrait Artist of the Year. It covers:
  • the three sitters
  • the nine artists
  • self-portrait submissions
  • themes arising in the episode
  • who the sitters chose
  • the shortlist for a place in the semi-finals of PAOTY 2026
  • the winner
  • the sitters for the next episode.

Episode 7: The Sitters


Unusually this week, the three sitters are all women. They are:
  • Deborah Meaden - a British businesswoman and entrepreneur. She has been a member of the Panel of the BBC Show Dragon's Den for the last 20 years. She is also an animal lover and supporter of all things which are environmentally sound and supports related charities.
  • Jung Chang - a Chinese-born British author. She is best known for her family autobiography Wild Swans, which has sold over 10 million copies worldwide but is banned in the People's Republic of China.
  • Danielle de Niese - an Australian-American lyric soprano who has developed an operatic career. She sings in productions all over the world and she's currently appearing in a show in the West End of London.

Episode 7: The Artists


The Artists of Episode 7
L to R: Loi Linton, George Frederick Thomas, Andrew James, Helena Bowes,
Misaki Parbrook, Pierce Victor, Kate Herbert Roach, Monica Vittorino
Noemi Conen

The Episode 7 artists include everybody from 
  • people who don't paint portraits very often to 
  • professional artists who have been painting portraits on commission for decades.
I highlight links to those self portrait submissions that I thought were impressive.
  • Helena Boase - originally from Wiltshire and now based in London. She completed her self portrait in two hours. Her website suggests she is much more interested in plein air painting of landscapes and doesn't often paint portraits. She also offers an art advisory and creative consultancy services. I was bemused as to why she was selected. (Or should we conclude nobody looks at websites / instagram??)
  • Noemi Conen (Instagram) - Born in Warsaw, Poland, now based in South London. She studied Painting at Glasgow School of Art and completed the Drawing Year at the Royal Drawing School in 2022, She is pursuing an MFA at the Slade. Her submission was a double self portrait in biro on canvas. Here's a link to her drawings on canvas  which includes her large double self portrait submission - with a cat smoking! This is her comment on her own unusual practice
Drawing on canvas. Or is it painting. Why does it matter, exactly?

I have always been attracted by the quality of markmaking a simple biro is capable of. I used it a lot in sketchbooks but it wasn’t until the Summer after the first year at Slade, when I abandoned most of my materials with the international student storage that I tried biro on canvas. It is definitely not made for that purpose, but I love to struggle.
  • George Frederick Thomas (Instagram) - grew up in Gloucestershire and now based in London. Studied at the London Atelier of Representational Art (LARA) 2014 – 2017. He also works as a live event artist.
  • Kate Herbert Roche (Instagram) - lives in Uckfield in East Sussex. She graduated with a BA in Fine Art from the University of Gloucestershire in 2007 and has exhibited with the Royal Society of Portrait Painters, NEAC and Chelsea Art Society. Kate takes inspiration from the Sussex landscape, and from the people and the class-based diversity of her surroundings, past and present. I thought her self portrait was impressive
  • Andrew James VPRP, NEAC (Instagram) - Described by the programme as "a professional artist" based in Tunbridge Wells. Probably better known to many professional portrait painters as a former Vice President and current Council Member of the Royal Society of Portrait Painters and the 2024 winner of the Ondaatje Prize for Portraiture (worth £10,000). I'm going to have a chat with him about why he chose to do the programme.
  • Loi Lynton (Instagram) - a Birmingham born and based contemporary portrait and oil painter whose work explores Afro-Futurism. She provides absolutely nothing about herself on her website - which is a mistake.
  • Misaki Parbrook (Instagram) -  a contemporary Japanese-Irish oil painter who splits her time between Ireland and Japan, where she studies Urushi (Japanese lacquer which has been around for over 9000 years). She grew up in Ireland, graduated with First Class Honours in BA Fine Art Painting from the National College of Art and Design (NCAD), and has also lived in Kyoto. Her practice draws on personal memory, journeying, and the quiet spaces between places and people. Her self portrait submission Drift II (2025) was very unusual and eye-catching. I've been watching it on the title credits all series. (Note: The winner of the series always has their self portrait in the title credits all series.)
Working with limited colour palettes and an interest in monochrome, her process is intuitive and focused on rhythm, stillness, and repetition. (National College of Art and Design)
  • Pierce Victor (Instagram) - a London-based artist, illustrator, and multidisciplinary designer working across fine art, digital illustration, graphic design, and motion graphics.
  • Monica Vittorino (Instagram) - born in Portugal, now lives in London. She used to be an architect and she is now an artist. She paints in watercolour and was the 2024 RI @cassart1984 prize winner

Episode 7: The Self Portrait Submissions


PAOTY 2026 Episode 7: The Self Portrait Submissions
PAOTY 2026 Episode 7: The Self Portrait Submissions
(left to right: Loi Linton, George Frederick Thomas, Andrew James,
Helena Bowes, Misaki Parbrook, Pierce Victor, Kate Herbert Roche,
Monica Vittorino, Noemi Conen)

Another episode in which we are seeing bigger "commission worthy" self portraits 

I would argue that the selection of at least four of the artists for the shortlist was pretty much sewn up by their submissions alone. The issue would largely be focused on how to reduce to three!

Format:
1 x landscape
8 x portrait

Size:
1 x extra large
3 x large

0 x large medium
2 x medium
3 x small
0 x very small

Drift II - Misaki Parbrook's self portrait submission

I really liked:
  • Misaki Parbrooks's landscape format/content - VERY unusual, rooted in a Japanese approach to art and one which I've been eyeing up in the title credits each week as belonging to a possible winner. (the title credits always include the winner's self portrait in every episode)
  • Kate Hudson-Roche's complete figure sat down - classic whole figure portrait pose
  • Noemi Conan's drawing of two versions of herself - because I love people who draw using pen and ink (in this case biro) and also people who draw big!

Episode 7: Themes and Learning Points


Portrait Painters with "status"


When a heat includes a long time professional portrait artist who is a member of the Royal Society of Portrait Painters it's always interesting to hear what the Judges have to say. >Andrew James - like >Jonathan Yeo - has had no formal art school education. Andrew James - unlike Jonathan Yeo - has been elected to leading art societies.

Indeed Andrew James is a Council Member of the Royal Society of Portrait Painters, a member of the Selection Committee in 2026. He was also elected Vice President in 2008 for a period of time. He's also got a much coveted membership of the New English Art Club.



Jung Chang reviews Andrew James's portrait of her

I had the very distinct impression while watching the programme that maybe, during the heat, one of the Judges (Jonathan Yeo?) took a look at his website and suddenly realised who he was!

Jonathan's comment - which seemed to come half way through the heat was
"He obviously likes gestural marks and heightened use of colour"
Eva described him as
"walking the line between figuration and abstraction".

Which immediately made me think that Eva has not looked at enough portraits by professional portrait painters! (See more comments below)

While the PAOTY Commission worth £10,000 is a lot of money for some of the participants, it's actually Andrew's standard fee for a large portrait (30 x 40inches)!


The Use of Photography to develop a Portrait

I've mentioned many times when writing these reviews, that there are excellent and practical reasons why artists use digital images to work from in the heats. Unusual distance from the sitter and techie/TV people getting in the way being the main ones.

However, my mouth dropped when I heard this statement by Katy Hessel
"What's quite interesting is she is using a black and white photograph to create a colour image"
She made it sound novel! I can only assume that she is TOTALLY UNAWARE of the routine practices of many portrait artists (and indeed artists generally) who use photography to help with the composition and development of their artwork).

Converting a colour photograph to monochrome to create a greyscale picture of the tones involved is a VERY typical practice. It helps identify the tonal pattern. Indeed, depending on how you manipulate the monochrome tones you can ratchet up and down on the number of tones which are shown

Doing this enables an artist to render the hue in the intended artwork with a complete knowledge of relevant tones. 

Too often we see artists rendering hues in various degrees of lightness and darkness of colour without any clear understanding of the actual tonal pattern which is evident within the subject - if you know how to look.

Far from being "novel", this practice of using monochrome to develop both compositions and colour notes has
  • been around for a very, very, very long time.
  • It's one of the reasons many artists develop monochrome drawings BEFORE they start painting.
  • It was also one of the very early lessons I had in "how to improve your artwork". 

(My studies being limited to various evening drawing classes at Central Saint Martin's and The Royal Drawing School - and various studies from art history after I took early retirement eg the Notan used by Georgia O'Keeffe)

See my various past posts on this topic during the early days of this blog

Maybe I need to start highlighting them again?

(I have an awful tendency to think because I've written about something once that everybody read it - and forget to allow for new followers who don't have a clue about the fact eg I had a Composition and Design Project running all year in 2008!)

Although I did do a fairly recent post titled My Composition and Design project (2025)

Greyscale and Value Finder - you can buy these in various formats
and they're very useful!

Judges' Obsessions #1: Story telling / Narrative


The Judges seem to be very intent on looking for narrative and storytelling within the four hour heat portraits.
I felt as if the judges were trying to direct the artists in the way they wanted them to paint - referring to their submission portraits and asking them how they were going to bring the same sort of interpretation to the heat portraits. Leave them alone and let them paint the way they want to! Comment on my Facebook page
I think they're absolutely crackers. In the space of four hours you tend to focus on achieving a good likeness and do what you can to link into clues about the background of the individual. You save the context and any storytelling for the commission proper - which (yet again) is why the self portrait submission is so important!

What we got from the most experienced professional artist in the heat was a decent size colour sketch - of the type most professional artists do prior to a commission. That, to my mind, is the proper baseline for what's required in a heat IF you have demonstrated that you can paint proper portraits in your self portrait submission.

While most artists tend to ignore the item that the sitter brings, some artists try to include it. Whether it tells the correct story about the sitter is quite another matter.

Looking for evidence of a capacity for story telling is much more relevant to the submissions of self portraits.

(Note: I think I'm going to do a future blog post about narrative and storytelling in artwork.)

The Judges do the half time discussion with Stephen Mangan

ALSO I wrote in my notes the following
Discussion Half Way: A lot of it is about what Judges are 
  • either "making up"
  • or "not understanding the process the artist has adopted"

Leading on from that I keep getting a VERY distinct feeling that these three Judges have very little intimate acquaintance with HOW many artists work in terms of techniques, skills and normal practice.  

I've had "Oh Really???!!!" total guff moments in every episode so far.

Neither Katy Hessell or Eva Langret appear to have ANY practical experience of being an artist and/or how they work.
She (Eva) is known for her sharp critical eye and commitment to platforming underrepresented voices in the art world. (Sky Group Press Release)
For example, I know Jonathan Yeo has never had an art school education 
When I left school at the end of the 1980s, there weren’t many options if you wanted to go and learn how to paint. At that time there was really only one art school in London teaching painting and pretty much everywhere it was seen as an old-fashioned genre and medium. So, I tried to make a living as a painter for a year and failed miserably. It was a disaster. I didn’t know what I was doing and so was persuaded to study something rather than get a job

I had access to a studio space owned by my grandmother and spent most of my spare time, weekends and holidays trying to paint. I also enrolled in some life classes. These were the closest I got to learning anything formally. (Jonathan Yeo on his "art education" | Jonathan Yeo's website)
I should point out that I was doing my evening Life Classes at Central Saint Martins in the 80s! The ability to draw caricature is no substitute for a decent class in life drawing - and just drawing, drawing, drawing!

More on Judge's Obsessions / Comments / Claptrap / Bingo Card(?)


It turns out I'm far from being alone in my views of the irrelevance or questionability of some of the Judges' comments.

This was left as a comment on my Facebook Page. An insightful critique of words used by Judges turned up - and needs wider sharing.


Anybody got any other words Judges use without proper and well informed consideration?

Including Hands


Including hands in a portrait is a sure way of showing Judges that you can paint more than a head. It indicates you can also take on a "proper portrait". 

You also need to be an artist pretty confident in your own abilities if you paint hands - as they are not an easy thing to paint.

The hands below are at an early stage and are certainly not perfect - but it was very good to see somebody prepared to make the effort.

Hands in the portrait of Deborah Meaden by Monica Vittorino

Using a Long Brush


George Frederick Thomas was heard explaining why he likes using a long brush which he summarised rather well. I made quick notes and wrote down:
  • forces you to think about the shapes at the start
  • enables you to see the canvas and the model at the same time
  • helps you get a good likeness straight off.
There was just one issue which is that his painting of Danielle was not the best likeness - but definitely caught something of her. I think it might also have been a lot better if he'd gone much bigger on his support.

Why a stool?


One of the better innovations of this series was everybody sitting in a chair which provided good back support, a comfy seat - and not a lot of scope for moving around.

I was therefore greatly bemused by the fact that a woman in a black velvet evening gown with a big slit up the side (Danielle de Niese) was sat on a stool!!!

I hope she asked for a stool as to give her one in that dress and ask her to sit still for four hours would be torture!
"I was there on the day, she moved around a LOT which made it difficult for them. Velvet dress on a stool with no back probably didn’t help!" (One of my facebook commentators)

Portraits and the Judging


Below you first see the portraits as the artists turn them round and then see which sitter chose what. It's a fleeting moment and one very much worth seeing again.

Who the Sitters Chose


Jung Chang


The paintings of Jung Chang 
by (L to R) Noemi Conan, Andrew James and Misaki Parbrook

Jung Chang liked all her portraits. She chose the one with two heads of her created in biro by Noemi Conan. 

Deborah Meaden


The portraits of Deborah Meaden
by (L to R) Loi Linton, Helena Boise and Monica Vittorino
(I'm afraid Loi was a little slow on her turn - hence no pic)

TIP: Learn how to move your easel - before you need to - so that you can keep up with your group on the turn!

Deborah Meaden decided that 
"all of them look like me!"
She chose the portrait by the artist she seemed to converse the most with during the programme - Helena Boise (in the middle)

Here's Loi's painting of Deborah which I really liked.


Danielle De Niece


The paintings of Danielle De Neice
by (L to R) George Frederick Thomas, Pierce Victor and Kate Herbert Roche

Danielle de Niese chose the very flattering but unfinished (and smallest) portrait by George Frederick Thomas. 

(Decoding Note: When I use the term "flattering" I mean that the portrait is not actually an accurate likeness of the sitter)

I personally thought Kate Herbert Roche's painting was a much better portrait - and much better finished - but perhaps more accurate than the sitter would like to be seen? It was also well sized relative to her canvas - which is always really nice to see. It speaks of experience!


The Shortlist


Yet again, absolutely no discussion of the completed portraits which were not shortlisted at this stage. 

As if comments passed at an earlier stage of the heat on unfinished portraits are adequate and the artists don't need to spend their time towards the end of painting time to correcting any mistakes made earlier!!

To my mind it is just plain disrespectful - and also reveals a total lack of understanding by both Judges and the Production Team about how artists learn from paintings that don't succeed and the mistakes made by other artists. There is a reason why Art Schools do Group Critique Sessions!

Waiting to hear the decision about who wins

The Shortlist selected by the Judges was:
  • Andrew James
  • Masaki Parbrook
  • Noemi Conen
There was pretty universal consensus on Facebook that these were the right three painters.

Paintings by the three artists shortlisted to win Episode 7
Left to right: Misaki Parbrook, Noemi Conan and Andrew James

Very unusually, they were all the painters in the Jung Chang section!

and so, in alphabetical order....

Andrew James


Andrew James: Self Portrait Submission and Heat Portrait

Stephen Mangan commented that Andrew James has provided a burst of colour in both his portraits. He asked why is Andrew in the final three?

Eva's response was they loved the conversation between figuration and abstraction - which he was able to repeat again successfully in the heat.
"This is absolutely Jung's face....around that she's sort of grounded within the sort of abstract moments, which she herself wasn't quite able to recognise. She asked "what's this in my hair?" "
Jonathan would have liked to see a bit more attention to the eyes which would have elevated the portrait to an extraordinary level.

Misaki Parbrook


All the Judges notes that Jung Chang's mother had passed away just a week ago. This was the individual who provided her with 60 hours of taped stories which Jung used to write "Wild Swans".

Misaki Parbrook: Self Portrait submission and Heat Portrait

I think Misaki asks really interesting questions
How do you represent a person across time and maybe space. And I think she was really able to capture this in her submission Eva Langret
Katy Hessel asked

Are we walking past a fresco or a tapestry of these people? You know this is her replicated but what is she pondering in this work? There are so many layers to it and I find it incredibly intriguing
Jonathan Yeo said

I guess today the one thing I was perhaps unsure about was whether she would be able to convey a sense of the sitter's personality. But I think she's answered that extremely well. It's sort of optimisitic, but there's a sadness in the eyes as well.

My take on it (having looked at her website - which I think all good judges should do!) is Misaki is not asking questions so much as endeavouring to explore her heritage and find a way within contemporary art to utilise some of the stylistic devices used by Japanese art in the past - which often has a particular focus on storytelling and the use of Ukiyo-e as a mark-making method which underpinned large series of prints.

(See my 2008 project on Japanese Art and Hokusai and Hiroshige on my blog which is summarised in An introduction to Japanese Art on Making A Mark  - plus some more posts I've written since relating to Japanese art)

Katy also needs to look more closely - there are different people in the submission!


Noemi Conan


Noemi Conan: Self Portrait Submission and Heat Portrait

Noemi focused on double portraits in both her paintings. Why is the double portrait such a theme this year when it never has been before?

Noemi has an ability to both express a good likeness but also feelings.

Katy Hessel thought she was more successful in her heat portrait than her submission.

Eva thought that there was an artist to artist connection of two individuals whose families have migrated to other lands and share a history of displacement.

I think the latter while true is over-egging the interpretation. I thought it more likely she had the death of her mother in mind. We don't know what she looked like - but many daughters look like their mothers.

Jonathan commented on biro not being considered an art material and it being refreshing to see somebody using it an imaginative way is exciting.



PAOTY 2026 Episode 7 Winner



The winner of Episode 7 is Misaki Parbrook.


Waiting to hear the winner


Jonathan Yeo said at the end of the heat
I think the thing which excites me about Masaki is she's not afraid to try different ways of doing portraits. She can render skin tones and get a good sense of human presence. And then, on top of that, she brings awareness of the possibilities of narrative and certainly playing with your expectations and perhaps even the genre itself.
My thoughts are that Misaki is a genuine contemporary original whose style is rooted in thematic and characteristic styles employed in Japan in the past. It's always exciting to see an artist using heritage to inform their contemporary practice.

If anybody asked me to predict I think she's going to win this series.

_________________________________________


- and want to keep up with my reviews
and get an email to your inbox every time I publish
________________________________________

Next Episode


The next episode is the one I went to watch in the afternoon - and hence you get an added EXTRA with an album of most of the photos I took on the day which give you a much better insight into what it looks like in real life - and how they film it, featuring the absolutely enormous boom and the small lady who operates it!

The very big boom camera - operated by a very small woman

The sitters for the next episode are:
  • Food Critic Grace Dent
  • Comedian Munya Chawawa
  • Comedian Grace Campbell (daughter of Alistair Campbell)


REFERENCE: PAOTY SERIES 13 (2026)


YOU CAN READ ALL MY BLOG POSTS ABOUT PREVIOUS SERIES
BY LOOKING AT THE REFERENCE SECTION
AT THE END OF THE CALL FOR ENTRIES POST

No comments:

Post a Comment

COMMENTS HAVE BEEN CLOSED AGAIN because of too much spam.
My blog posts are always posted to my Making A Mark Facebook Page and you can comment there if you wish.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.