Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Review: Discerning Eye 2026 Exhibition

One of the most intriguing exhibitions of the year is the annual Discerning Eye Exhibition, held at the Mall Galleries in London. 
The Discerning Eye aims to encourage wider conversations around the understanding and appreciation of the visual arts
This is prestigious art exhibition which showcases small-scale artworks by UK-based artists
  • The 2026 exhibition opened last week and continues until 21 November 2026 - 10am to 5pm daily
  • Entry is totally free
  • Every work is for sale!
  • this is the online version of the exhibition
This exhibition is always unique and different. This is because each year because six different individuals are invited to:
  • select SMALL artwork from the response to the open entry
    Every work MUST BE under 50cm in any direction for sale.

  • invite artists they know to contribute to the exhibition with other small artworks
Six independent selectors reviewed more than 6,800 entries and have chosen around 700 works spanning painting, drawing, printmaking, sculpture, and photography. 
They've actually chosen 748 artworks - and it's TOO MUCH!


Selectors


This year's selectors are listed below in their three categories. 
The link in their names goes to their website and about details

Artists

Art Critics / Commentators

  • Financial Times art critic and economist Melanie Gerlis
  • Head of Culture at the London Standard Martin Robinson (Instagram)

Art Collectors

What they choose is entirely up to the individual selectors - and I always see six different exhibitions - and sometimes, like this year, some VERY different exhibitions - as I found this year

The aim is to blend both emerging artists and those who are more experienced. To this end, as well as selecting artwork from the open entry, the selectors can also invite more established artists to participate in their exhibition.

What you make of this exhibition depends on:

  • what your background with art is, 
  • whether you buy it 
  • how many exhibitions you look at.
PLUS 
  • how many exhibits the selectors choose
  • how good the selectors are at curation
In relation to the first half of what influences people's views

I took my other half JR with me (who doesn't usually come with me - but we were in town and he has started buying small impressionist works to go with his historical prints!). I think he found it all a bit overwhelming. Unfortunately he has a nose for the less than wonderful and immediately pointed out the dirty power socket to me - halfway down the first wall he'd looked at. I looked at it and wondered what on earth Melanie Girlis was thinking when she selected this. I felt sorry for the artwork which was shown close to it.  He then went looking for more "not very good art" and decided he'd found too much to make it worthwhile looking at the better examples - and went home!

This was all very unexpected. However sometimes going with someone who isn't used to sifting and sorting visually can be a bit of an eyeopener. Plus make you think how this can be avoided in future.

To be honest, I couldn't look at the crowded walls for long and can remember very little of them - except by looking at my photos.

I always say I always known when I've seen a good exhibition because I can remember it and walk around it in my head for days afterwards.

A crowded exhibition - more than usual

I must confess the exhibition not only lokked VERY crowded to me - particularly in the West Gallery - it was very crowded!

According to the online exhibition there are 748 exhibits in the show - marginally bigger than last year - BUT THE NUMBER HAS BEEN GROWING EVERY YEAR

2025: 727
2024: 685
2023: 628
2022: 420
2019: 457
2018: 491
2017: 465

In the past selectors tended to hang around 100 with a number hanging less.

As an exhibition, it was certainly better curated and looked better when the number of works exhibited were under 500 in total

Which made me think maybe JR had a point - maybe the selectors did not have or had not exercised curatorial skills and had a bit too much to hang.

I tried to work out the exhibits by selector. You can look at what everybody chose by clicking on their pic on this page https://discerningeyeexhibition.co.uk/

So the totals are from most to least:
  • 150 artworks - Kelvin Okafor
  • 127 artworks - Martin Robinson
  • 123 artworks - Melanie Girlis
  • 122 artworks - Hugh Bonneville 
  • 119 artworks - Jasmine Pradissitto 
  • 109 artworks - Jon Sharples
So every selectors has chosen more than 100, whereas for the majority of years this exhibition has been running, it's more normal for some selectors to have less than 100. Certainly pre Covid (see total artworks exhibited above re the years I looked at.)

So one has to ask,
  • Are the six "Discerning Eyes" discerning enough? Did they choose too much? Have they curated before?
  • Were they given clear guidance on how many to choose?
  • Do they know how to hang?
The two with the most artworks (Kelvin Okafor and Martin Robinson) got a gallery to themselves - which certainly helped how they were displayed

The remaining four are all in the West Gallery - with the two with the most artworks being hung on the two long walls.

A good Discerning Eye Exhibit by a selector tells a story - because the selector has come along knowing what sort of art they like and what they want to display. They actively filter and curate.

Melanie Girlis exhibit on one of the long walls

Melanie Girlis was good at connecting colours and tended to put punchier pieces towards the middle line. She also tended to choose still life and natural history artworks which created a thread of connection across the line of artworks

I hated the ledge in front of the dirty plug sockets - I just thought it was really  disrespectful to some very finely worked pieces.

Jasmine Pradissiotto got the end wall and the feature wall near the end - which are usually regarded as good walls to hang on. Plus she had a LOT of 3D artworks on plinths on the floor of the gallery

She's an artist and she knows how to hang.

View of the end wall of the West Gallery
- hung by Jasmine Pradissiotto

I liked the build up to the middle from the left and then descent on the right - which she used on both of the larger spaces.

Feature wall in West Gallery
- hung by Jasmine Pradissiotto

I liked how she hung this wall - drawings and precision at the top, texture through the middle and very small works at the bottom - with colour notes connecting.

Hugh Bonneville got the other long wall and had a HUGE number of artworks about people and faces.

a lot of faces hung by Hugh Bonneville

A very crowded display
Hugh seems to like strong colour
- whether monochrome or in colours

Jon Sharples got what I always think of as the Brian Sewell slot (often used for the selector with the least artworks) - working its way from the end of one long wall, across two feature walls with 3D artwork sitting next to people drinking their coffees.

the Jon Sharples corner

I loved his doggy wall - a subtheme of his exhibition!

The Jon Sharples Doggy Wall

If you go to the Royal Academy of Arts Summer Exhibition you will often see a cat wall - or an awful lot of cats in close proximity - because cats sell well. So for those devoted to dogs, there's only one place to be in this exhibition!

I loved "Matisse's dogs in love" by Mychael Barrett Past President of the Royal Society of Painter Printmakers.

Martin Robinson in (most of) the East Gallery
view from the side door

Martin Robinson has one large space in the East Gallery with some plinths for the 3D artwork. I couldn't quite work out what interested most and in the end decided that this might be the most eclectic exhibition - with lots and lots of 3D artwork both large and small.

Martin Robinson in (most of) the East Gallery
view from the opposite corner

The ONLY artist who did the exhibition and the venue justice was Kelvin Okafor - because he had a beautifully curated exhibition hung in the three small rooms of the North Gallery. The gallery space overall is small but can, with the right hang, pack a punch. It was also the exhibit which made it easiest to see all the artwork as individual pieces - because 
  • they were not crowded
  • they typically enjoyed a maximum of two rows on a wall. Some were just one row.
Artwork selected by Kelvin Okafor

Kelvin Okafor's exhibition got this comment from me while I was still in the exhibition
Artist Kelvin Okafor, one of the 6 selectors for the ING Discerning Eye exhibition has by far the best exhibition! Made up of a great selection from the open entries and some work by invited artists. Plus extremely well hung. It’s a very classy exhibition!
A group of still life paintings
- clearly demonstrating why "less is more"

I think he was one of those who took the opportunity to invite works by artists he admired

Charcoal drawings by Julian Court

CONCLUSION AND REITERATION


This exhibition contains some good work - but it some of it very much needs a better edit

This is what I wrote in 2024 - and it bears repeating. When an exhibition makes people leave because there is too much hung, and there is too much which does not deserve to be hung....

The lesson for the future 
I think the lesson from this - if anybody is listening - is to: 
  • REMEMBER LESS IS MORE
  • limit every single Judge to no more than 100 artworks - and if they want less, less is fine
  • limit every Judge to having no more than 25% of the work exhibited from artists they have invited.
  • place an absolute emphasis on artists who are new to the Mall Galleries - for no other reason than this also then makes the exhibition a refreshing change for the viewing public.

To this I would add that every artist with artworks in excess of 100 should be asked to lose at least 10% of their initial selection. 

To curate AND EDIT!

Below is a list of the prizewinners. I wasn't particularly looking out for them - and there was so much on the wall the labels for prizewinners were not easy to see....
 

- and want to keep up with my reviews
and get an email to your inbox every time I publish



The 2026 Prizewinners...


Discerning Eye Founder's Prize, in honour of Michael Reynolds, £2,500: 
  • Olivia Arts, Kavinya, selected by Kelvin Okafor.
BDO Purchase Prize, £2,000: 
  • Arabella Greenhill, Everything / Everyone Has A Story, selected by Jasmine Pradissitto.
Nurole Purchase Prize, £1,500: 
  • Melanie Bellis, Transit, selected by Jasmine Pradissitto.
Discerning Eye Chair's Purchase Prize, £1,000: 
  • Sally Fitchard, Local Casting (Stoke-on-Trent), selected by Hugh Bonneville
Mervyn Metcalf Purchase Prize, £500: 
  • Laura Carey, Gossip 2, selected by Hugh Bonneville.
Adelaide Damoah Purchase Prize, £500: 
  • Nibras Al-Salman, The Man Who Lost His Mind Because He Read Too Many Books, selected by Jasmine Pradissitto.
Tabish Khan's Critic Purchase Prize, £250: 
  • Emily Bartlett, When Did Sunlight Become a Machine, selected by Melanie Gerlis.
Sculpture Prize, £500: 
  • Hamish Holman, Orbital, selected by Kelvin Okafor.
Cityscape Prize, £500: 
  • Jenny Pockley, Indigo Waterloo Bridge, selected by Jasmine Pradissitto.
Landscape Prize, £500: 
  • Jayne Stokes, Northern Territory, selected by Kelvin Okafor.
Anthony Lester Portrait Prize, £500: 
  • Dylan Lisle, The Imaginary Deathmask of Maya Angelou, selected by Kelvin Okafor.
Print Prize, £500: 
  • Barrie Watts, The Meadow Oak, selected by Melanie Gerlis.
Drawing Prize, £500: 
  • Lex Art, Only by Faith, invited by Kelvin Okafor.
The Drawing Prize
Lex Art, Only by Faith, invited by Kelvin Okafor


Photography Prize, £500: 
  • Gayle Hallowell, Root Chorus, selected by Martin Robinson.
Art Ladder Prize, worth £600: one year's subscription to The Art Ladder mentoring programme for artists and two one-to-one mentoring sessions. 
  • Vivienne Vela, Homeward Bound, selected by Hugh Bonneville.

REFERENCE


No comments:

Post a Comment

COMMENTS HAVE BEEN CLOSED AGAIN because of too much spam.
My blog posts are always posted to my Making A Mark Facebook Page and you can comment there if you wish.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.